I went to see I Am Legend last night and thought it was a pretty good action flick. Without Will Smith, however, it would have been a ’so-so’ movie at best. He’s one of those actors that can make you ignore plot and scripting shortfalls.
The movie differs significantly from the book. So different, in fact, that you can’t really discuss which version was ‘better’. The book had a darker, more complex ending for sure (although the movie doesn’t exactly end with a ‘happily ever after’ either) but the special effects in the movie are pretty powerful and a even a mildly active imagination will force you to enjoy the post apocalyptic mayhem of the film.
The evil doers of the film were pretty two dimensional but gave a few small hints at being more interesting. Either there were some scenes left on the cutting room floor (wait for the DVD!) or, when combined with the ending, it may have been a set up for a sequel (which I do not think would be particularly good).
The original film, with Vincent Price, was closer to the book (you can watch it here) but it has it’s own faults and, in my opinion, the movie has difficulty in capturing the despair Neville feels in the book or the sense of how empty the world is in the story. I watched it again recently but it didn’t do much for me.
Another movie called Cloverfield will be kickin’ the crap out of NYC soon. I don’t have high hopes for this one. It looks like the Blair Witch Project meets Godzilla where a bunch of clueless 20-somethings decide to film a huge monsters assault on the city. The movie obviously intends on making a lot of mileage out of the fact that they have the monster decapitate the Statue of Liberty. That’s fine with me but if you have to reference that gimmick three or more times in a two minute trailer I’m guessing you don’t have much else to show.