Marjah Roundup

Well the Moshtarak offensive is well under way and there’s lots of reporting out there on it.  If you’d like some more info, may I suggest:

Start with this backgrounder by the Institute for the Study of War titled, Operation Moshtarak: Preparing for the Battle of Marjah.  A nice 6 page (2 of which are notes) paper which does quite a good job of providing some context to the battle .  As a product I thought it was well organized, nicely edited and adequately sourced (although I wasn’t familiar with many of those sources and so wasn’t able to evaluate those).  I’d be really happy to see a product like this come out of a shop I was working in.

The NY Times has some nice graphics if you’re looking to build your own TOC.  They also link the articles to the specific maps.  It’s nice but some basic operational graphics would help explain the story a bit and wouldn’t compromise operational security any more than the text does.

ISAF is certainly trying harder to go beyond the simple press release in its information campaign.  It may not be super sophisticated but it’s miles ahead of where they were in 2001.

The other big news of the day is that Abdul Baradar has been in custody for a few days now (prepare for blather about coddling him for not ripping his fingernails out or hooking up a car battery to his genitals).  The timing, coming simultaneously with the operations in Marjah may be fortuitous for Gen. McChrystal.  I’m just happy we got someone other than another ‘number 3 man’ in the organization.

The Atlantic discusses the possible implications with it’s own roundup of the issue.

Steve Coll keeps us from getting to giddy from the good news:

The Taliban are weak and vicious, but they are not dumb. Strategic withdrawal has been at the heart of their war strategy since the fall of Kandahar in December 2001. For the Obama Administration’s policy to succeed, U.S. and Afghan forces must secure Afghanistan’s major cities, its major highways, and as many provincial towns and populated rural areas in Taliban country as possible, and by doing so, persuade the Taliban and their allies that they cannot stage a second revolution anytime soon – and so, therefore, should consider political negotiations. Afghanistan is a big country. Kandahar is critical to the Taliban. Whatever the durability of the current operation, the Helmand River Valley is not likely to be this war’s decisive locus.


3 responses to “Marjah Roundup

  1. Trying to figure out what the US Army is doing during this time. Are we (again) letting the Marines steal the limelight after all the work done by the majority member of the coalition forces? Can’t seem to find any info, not from the www. page,, anywhere, on Army forces deployed or actions during this offensive.

    • According to ISAF, marines make up most of the U.S. for in the Marjah campaign (3 x battalions and a light armed recon regiment for the marines and 1 Striker BN and 1 Combat engineer BN for the Army).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s